Similar experiments have been carried out between Juventus superstar Cristiano Ronaldo and legendary Brazilian Ronaldo. Surprisingly, Keane opted for a midfield two of Paul Ince and Bryan Robson, omitting Scholes from the team entirely. Its while it is worth noting that these are not a true reflection on the ability of each player. pubeboy Additional comment actions Just another view though. Gerrard never in top 3, but very close Scholes nowhere near top 3 Highest Ballon D'or Finish Lampard 2nd - one time Gerrard 3rd - one time Scholes nowhere near top 3 Premier League Team of the Year Appearances Gerrard 8 Lampard 5 Scholes 2 Premier League Player of the Month Awards Gerrard 6 Lampard 4 Scholes 4 People who have no idea how absolutely ridiculous a player Robson was. Matches, Goals, Assists, Yellow Cards, Red Cards, Playing Time, Awards, Trophy \u0026 More. Keane played alongside Paul Scholes for many years at Old Trafford (Image: GETTY) After spending 20 years playing for Manchester United, Scholes retired from professional football in 2013, at 38 years of age. Comparatively, Lampard and Gerrard played their last season in England at 36 and 35 years of age and both never produced higher than an 85% pass completion rate in any season throughout their entire careers. Seeing as how the name of the game in deep lying positions is ball distribution and ball retention, this only makes sense. The main stats we would look for here are dribbles completed, pass completion rate for both long and short passes, interceptions, tackle success rates and ball recoveries. Although he is well known as one of the greatest midfielders in English history, he actually started his career off as a striker. Despite the fact that Gerrards highest ranking is 3rd, Lampard wins this round. However, seeing as its all we have, and taking into consideration how dominant Lampards numbers are, Im quite comfortable with giving him the win in this category. Can't decide between sheffield university and Warwick Unviersity??? Once Guardiola had clarified that Ferdinand was asking who he thought was best, the City coach instantly responded: "All respect to Frank [Lampard], to Steven [Gerrard] but Paul Scholes is my favourite one. And, right off the bat, its worth noting that although they share many similarities, all three of these players had different responsibilities within their respective teams, this makes it difficult to compare them. Zinedine Zidane was his footballing idol growing up (a maestro capable of turning football into art) although Lionel Messi has brought him an equal amount of joy since first watching the Argentine play in 2005. What does it mean when someone says that you are self-critical? We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. It might come as a surprise to learn that none of the three players ever reached double figures and that Gerrard's pretty average-looking tally of seven set-piece goals gives him the victory. Yet another generational talent that is widely considered to be the best player in the history of his club. No. Another big win for Lampard who astonishingly bagged 27 goals from midfield in 2009/10 on his way to a third Premier League crown at Stamford Bridge. steven gerrard vs paul scholes [individual awards/achievements] 1x uefa club footballer of the year 8x pfa pl team of the year 3x fifa fifpro world xi 3x uefa team of the year 1x uefa cl final man of the match 6x pl player of the month 2x fa england player of the year 1x ballon d'or bronze award 4x liverpool player of the season 4x liverpool top goal scorer 1x uefa euro team of the tournament . (A Detailed Comparison), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window). And realistically, this argument can go either way. All three played football professionally for roughly two decades, so this is essentially an assessment on how effective they were able to remain, despite the natural evolution of the game over time. However, all the same, football is not only about statistics. Asked whether there were any. When you look into the similarities between these three individuals, based on their playing careers, its easy to see why the comparisons are so prevalent. Those aspects, to name a few, are first touch, aggression, composure, vision, defensive and offensive awareness and defensive and offensive positioning. Source () - Cropped and lightened version of the file uploaded to Flickr with the name scholsey5. A Scholes defender tweeted: "Roy Keane leaving out Scholes will give all the Gerrard Lampard were better lot ammunition. However, back in November, we looked at the response from 19 different footballers (current and former) who answered the Scholes vs Gerrard vs Lampard debate. He wins 3 of the 6 criteria, with Lampard in second place with 2, and Gerrard in third place with 1. Both Lampard and Scholes have scored three times for England away from qualifiers and friendlies, but we're giving second place to the latter for doing so across three separate tournaments. However, as a member of the team, they are entitled to take some responsibility for the achievements. Gerrard in his prime was a true box to box midfielder, capable of being at either end of the pitch at a moment notice and contributing greatly wherever he was. The Student Room and The Uni Guide are both part of The Student Room Group. And although - just like the Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo debate - there will never be a definitive answer, that hasn't stopped supporters from finding a way to score a knockout blow. After spending 17 years in Liverpool colors, Gerrard transferred to LA Galaxy in 2015. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Asked whether there were any current or former players he wishes he could have played with, the Arsenal legend responded with his answer almost immediately. Hi there! Please contact your account representative for further details. "It's probably more towards Toni Kroos, as a passer and more of a controlling player. what is the content of a finance/accounting module? Well, here's a look at the trio of Premier League legends through their career Ballon d'Or votes, and it paints a fascinating story. While these numbers are obviously elite, Scholes was just on another level in this department. A master at keeping possession and controlling the tempo of the game. Topics:.css-wpf514{color:#72B97D;}Frank Lampard, Liverpool, Paul Scholes, Football News, Chelsea, Football, Manchester United, Ballon d'Or, Steven Gerrard, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney confirm they are serious about signing Gareth Bale for Wrexham, Real Madrid in pursuit of Man Utd's Alejandro Garnacho with deal deemed 'very manageable', Perfect for Liverpool - Robbie Fowler urges Jurgen Klopp told to sign Newcastle's Joelinton, Jordan Pickford hilariously celebrates penalty save to deny James Maddison, fans are all saying the same thing, Sky Sports have spoken to Martin Tyler over Heung-Min Son comment he made in Liverpool vs Spurs commentary, BREAKING: Graeme Souness leaves Sky Sports after 15 years as a pundit, Virgil van Dijk had his left ankle and entire reputation shattered by Ivan Perisic's run, Steven Gerrard was 'on another planet' to Paul Scholes and Frank Lampard, Sven Goran Eriksson Settles Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard Or Paul Scholes Debate, Pep Guardiola picks Paul Scholes in the classic 'Gerrard, Lampard or Scholes' debate, Comparing Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard And Paul Scholes By Their Career Ballon d'Or Votes. Scholes probably gets the hipster choice, and became more popular as he got older as he was less of a sexy star player than Lampard or Gerrard and his style of play evolved as the Man U tactical system evolved with the input from Quiroz. It is, after all, the Premier League's equivalent of the Cristiano Ronaldo vs Lionel Messi saga with fans up and down the country putting forward their case across pub tables and living rooms. First things first, for anyone thats unaware of the background of these three players, let me provide you with a brief overview of their careers. This criterion included chances created, key passes, assists, pass completion, goals, dribbles competed, tackles won, distance covered and many more. . As a former world-class midfielder himself who is more than aware of English footballing culture, Guardiola knows one or two things about judging the merits of each legendary player. The Liverpool icon made the cut six times on the bounce between 2004 and 2009. Each players was born within 6 years of one another, Each spent almost the entirety of their career at one club, These clubs happen to be each others rivals, they each retired within three years of one another, and finally, they have all predominantly played in central midfield positions throughout their careers. The Irishman appeared on Sky Sports' flagship show for Manchester United's home match against Brentford on Monday night, where he was asked to name his ultimate Red Devils XI of the Premier League era. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. As previously stated, this is a measure of who was able to adapt better over the course of their career. So, heres how this assessment is going to work; Six separate categories will be used to compare each of these three players. As a side note, this is also a warning to anyone that sees any statistical comparisons between these three dating from before 2006 to just double check how complete the stats actually are and were they are getting them from. His ability to never lose the ball, dribble out of tight spaces, recycle possession, find players from deep and also contribute defensively and offensively was second to none, in my opinion. Ultimately, its all down to personal opinion. ", Topics:.css-wpf514{color:#72B97D;}Frank Lampard, Paul Scholes, Los Blancos, Football News, Football, Toni Kroos, Steven Gerrard, Real Madrid, La Liga, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney confirm they are serious about signing Gareth Bale for Wrexham, Real Madrid in pursuit of Man Utd's Alejandro Garnacho with deal deemed 'very manageable', Perfect for Liverpool - Robbie Fowler urges Jurgen Klopp told to sign Newcastle's Joelinton, Jordan Pickford hilariously celebrates penalty save to deny James Maddison, fans are all saying the same thing, Sky Sports have spoken to Martin Tyler over Heung-Min Son comment he made in Liverpool vs Spurs commentary, BREAKING: Graeme Souness leaves Sky Sports after 15 years as a pundit, Virgil van Dijk had his left ankle and entire reputation shattered by Ivan Perisic's run, Gerrard, Scholes and Lampard have been frequently compared by fans, Scholes, 45, has previously spoken with high admiration for Kroos and said he sees a bit of himself in the Germany captain, Steven Gerrard was 'on another planet' to Paul Scholes and Frank Lampard, Sven Goran Eriksson Settles Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard Or Paul Scholes Debate, Pep Guardiola picks Paul Scholes in the classic 'Gerrard, Lampard or Scholes' debate, Toni Kroos Has His Say On The Gerrard, Scholes, Lampard Debate. 3. Now onto individual achievements. The fallout continued even after Scholes' international retirement in 2004, with Gerrard and Lampard failing to work together in a midfielder two for the Three Lions. Between the mid 90s to roughly the early 2010s, England was blessed with a vast array of incredibly talented football players in virtually every position. Topics:.css-wpf514{color:#72B97D;}Liverpool, gaming news, Paul Scholes, Football News, FIFA 20, Football, Manchester United, REds, FUT, red devils, Premier League, EA Sports, Steven Gerrard, Ultimate Team, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney confirm they are serious about signing Gareth Bale for Wrexham, Real Madrid in pursuit of Man Utd's Alejandro Garnacho with deal deemed 'very manageable', Perfect for Liverpool - Robbie Fowler urges Jurgen Klopp told to sign Newcastle's Joelinton, Jordan Pickford hilariously celebrates penalty save to deny James Maddison, fans are all saying the same thing, Sky Sports have spoken to Martin Tyler over Heung-Min Son comment he made in Liverpool vs Spurs commentary, BREAKING: Graeme Souness leaves Sky Sports after 15 years as a pundit, Virgil van Dijk had his left ankle and entire reputation shattered by Ivan Perisic's run, often been debated alongside Frank Lampard over who was the best midfielder out of the trio, same experiment to compare Barcelona captain Lionel Messi with Argentine icon Diego Maradona, between Juventus superstar Cristiano Ronaldo and legendary Brazilian Ronaldo, compared United legend Nemanja Vidic against Liverpool star Virgil van Dijk, Steven Gerrard was 'on another planet' to Paul Scholes and Frank Lampard, Sven Goran Eriksson Settles Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard Or Paul Scholes Debate, Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard And Paul Scholes Ranked By 29 Attributes On FIFA 21, Thierry Henry Asked Who Is Better Out Of Paul Scholes And Steven Gerrard. I mean, I knew that Gerrard was quite prolific in terms of awards too, but I must admit that I was surprised at how close their personal trophy hauls are. When we use these stats alone as a basis for comparison, Lampard clearly wins. EDITORIAL USE ONLY. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.